The sophisticated readership of the RoRI Substack will likely already have guessed that, despite the adoption this month of the Kyoto Vision for a Golden Age of Science by the USA and 16 other countries from across the globe, the world of science is not on the cusp of anything particularly new or shiny.
For sure, science has its fair share of problems in need of redress and is grappling with the evident challenges and opportunities offered by the dramatic ascendancy of AI. But the announcement in Japan last week seems mainly just to have added another log on the fire of long-standing concerns.
On the face of it, the one-page Kyoto Vision is a sensible, if rather innocuous document, signalling support for new research funding mechanisms and institutions, the thoughtful integration of AI into scientific workflows, and efforts to cultivate the next generation of scientific talent – all without committing the signatory nations to any specific commitments. However, the brief vision statement leans heavily on Science: A New Golden Age, a much longer policy paper published by the Trump administration earlier this year1. It too has some reasonable things to say about the structural issues that afflict 21st Century science, and some interesting albeit not entirely original ideas for diversifying the funding and organisation of research, harnessing human capital, and energising public-private synergism. At the same time, Science: A New Golden Age is nostalgic, ahistorical, sweeping in some of its unsupported assertions, brimming with confidence in the power of AI, and avowedly nationalistic in its aims. I was going to write that within and between its lines, this policy document reveals more about the authors’ aims than they intended but perhaps it says exactly what they mean, and can be taken as a model for how populist politicians in other countries might seek to reshape their research systems.
An obvious omission from the policy is any recognition of the vitality and sense of common purpose that science derives from international collaborations. Telling also is its characterisation of universities. While recognised as “essential for training scientists and pursuing fundamental questions”, they are variously described as bureaucratic, expensive, hierarchical, siloed and out of touch. No one who has worked in a university would deny the kernels of truth in that pen portrait, but they would also recognise it as a caricature rather than the full picture. More worryingly, the policy proceeds from there to claim that scientific autonomy has been “inverted”. Rather than shielding researchers from external political meddling, it “has been cynically used as a shield against accountability, as scientific institutions are slow to police themselves, or even engage in political meddling of their own”. To many, this will sound like a partial truth drawn from a much bigger and more complex story, but it will also come across a bit rich coming from an administration that has cut funding to research topics it dislikes (such as climate science, gender research, misinformation and vaccine hesitancy) and threatened universities with financial penalties if they do not adopt policies aligned with the Trump White House.
Nevertheless, the attack on autonomy brings into focus the important question of where exactly lies the boundary between legitimate political interest in the formulation of research programmes and the intellectual independence of public research institutions. Responding in Science Business to their own governments’ adoption of the Kyoto Vision, the German Rectors’ Conference queried the reference to “new institutional models” and asserted that research funding should be “guided first and foremost by scientific not political principles”. Perhaps the German Rectors explained their position more fully in their response, but that bald statement sounds a bit tin-eared. It’s not exactly the starting point for constructive dialogue.
Fortunately, Professor Sarah de Rijcke, Rector Magnificus of Leiden University and a co-founder of RoRI, has recently offered a more cogent articulation of how to situate the ideals of academic freedom in the real world. The logic and experience underpinning the principles are laid out clearly in Sarah’s article, which is well worth reading in full – it has an honesty, integrity and openness that is largely lacking in Science: A New Golden Age; but in brief, these principles are:
Ground academic freedom in the duty to produce reliable knowledge
Protect questions that have value that cannot be shown in advance
Treat universities as democratic infrastructure
Hold security and openness as a single responsibility
Protect the people who carry the risk of independent work
Return the trust on which institutional autonomy rests
The particular value of this approach is that it engages, with clarity and humility, with the realities of the world, acknowledging that academic freedom is a privilege that exists in the liminal space between university autonomy and public accountability, and is therefore subject to continuous processes of negotiation. The unwritten contract with society is that rights to free enquiry bring with them duties and responsibilities.
Sarah’s formulation of the principles of academic freedom is also practical-minded. She offers them as (with my emphasis):
“…a set of principles that can guide real decisions in the messy situations academics face. They can be used as a test for any measure that affects universities, and apply to governments, funders and university leaders alike.
They are written for people who have to decide, often under time pressure, where legitimate steering of a publicly funded system ends and interference with independent knowledge begins. They concern both the freedom of academics to pursue questions wherever the evidence leads, and the ability of universities to protect that work from undue influence.”
As a university leader herself, Sarah will be all too aware of the difficulties inherent in enacting principles as new and challenging situations arise. In defending academic freedom, just as in science (and metascience), there will always be a plurality of perspectives and it is critical to enable these to be brought into constructive dialogue. The Kyoto Vision and the report it is founded on present one particular viewpoint on how science should advance, but history teaches us again and again that science is a dynamic social process that operates largely as a perpetual argument, or rather as an endless series of arguments about every aspect of how science is conducted and organised (some of which we have already visited on the Substack – see here and here).
A flavour of the disputatious essence of research can be tasted in reactions to two of the innovations suggested by Science: A New Golden Age. The report puts great store by the notion that science is in the midst of a replication ‘crisis’, a point of long-standing contention within the metascience community. The plan to “build verification infrastructure at scale” (already under way with the announcement by the NIH of a 5-year $175m programme to promote replication studies) will be music to some ears, while others hear only noise. Elsewhere, the proposal to create metascience units in every federal funding agency will be welcomed by some as a positive initiative that other nations are also embarking on (not least at RoRI where a forthcoming report of our MetaMoment project, due Nov 3rd, will aim to provoke discussion of the varieties of national metascience endeavours across the globe); however, there are also concerns that in the US the move amounts to a cynical co-option of metascience to further politicise the control of research funding.
Resolutions to these and other ongoing disputes will only be had through constructive engagement between diverse viewpoints. To that end, Geoff Mulgan, Professor of Collective Intelligence, Public Policy and Social Innovation at UCL, has helpfully posted a timely reminder of the precepts of healthy discourse. Geoff’s maxims were written primarily with the citizens of an ‘intelligent democratic society’ in mind but apply equally well to the society of scholars, not least because he regards healthy disagreement as “the friction and heat that’s essential to discovering new knowledge” and surely realises that even the most sophisticated citizens can lose sight of the rules of engagement in the heat of battle. Once again, the article is worth reading in full, but the rules are summarised succinctly:
Listen - let the other side speak and hear them out
Empathise - understand where they are coming from, and why they believe what they do
Surface your premises - be explicit about the grounds on which the argument could be settled
Calibrate your confidence - hold each belief with the confidence the evidence warrants, and no more
Be willing to change your mind - and treat doing so as a mark of success, not defeat.
Seek synthesis - look for a resolution that transcends the starting positions, or holds them in tension
Identify what remains unanswered - agree on what is unresolved and worth investigating further
For the wider citizenry, Geoff hopes that universities might be seen as institutions where good habits of argument are not just taught but practiced:
“Any graduate of any subject should leave with a feel for multiple perspectives, for a wide repertoire of ways of thinking, from data and models to disciplinary insights, introspection and deduction to imagination. They should be familiar with the best ways of thinking and arguing, including how to ask, repeatedly, ‘how would I know if I was wrong?”
Yet he notes that political pressures (from the left and the right), compounded by the tendency of financially-constrained universities “to act as revenue-maximising service providers rather than as agents of intelligence and social dialogue” have in recent years occasioned the suppression of full-throated discussion of topics that either side views as controversial or inappropriate.
These are hard times for our institutions of research and higher learning. We have seen some successful resistance to political pressure in the US, but some capitulations too. Those of use who would defend university autonomy and academic freedom face important challenges. To meet them we should pay more attention to the plurality, rather than the purity, of our endeavours. There may be little prospect of a new golden age, but at least we now have refreshed versions of the principles and tools to reaffirm our commitment to scientific practices that we know to thrive on humility, uncertainty and openness to change.
P.S. When finalising this piece, I was delighted to discover that the full title of Joseph Wright’s painting is “The Alchymist, in Search of the Philosopher’s Stone, Discovers Phosphorus, and prays for the successful Conclusion of his operation, as was the custom of the Ancient Chymical Astrologers.”
As this piece was ‘gong to press’ Stuart Buck, Aishwarya Khanduja and Hiya Jain published an interesting article on a Joint Memo by Michael Kratsios, the main author of Science: A New Golden Age, and Russ Vought (Office of Management and Budget, OMB), which is a shorter and potentially much more influential document since the OMB has greater control over the federal purse strings.




Excellent, thoughtful, review Stephen! Thanks for drawing these threads together. And thanks to Professor de Rijcke for articulating a great counter-point to the Golden Age manifesto
The is one kind of science that has not yet reached any recognized improvement in the Golden Age. It is the pseudo-science of macroeconomics. It is high time that the knowledge about our social business systems became a true science and replaced that past situation. Most economists who make this complaint do nothing to remedy it. However in my 320-page book "Consequential Macroeconomics--Rationalizing About How Our Social System Works" I have done more than grumble. I believe this is the first time a serious attempt has been made to rewrite national economics logically and scientifically. The plural perspectives Steve Curry mentioned apply here, too.
As a retired MSc. engineer, my research in what was a hobby topic has become more serious. I have managed to turn this vital topic into a true science that covers the whole of our system in a seamless way. This is unlike the pseudo version that cannot respond to the case where a change in part of our social system affects more than one other part of it.
For a free e-copy of this book please send me a short message of request for it. I will gladly respond and there is no obligation on the part of the would-be reader, nor is this a scam. chestdher@gmail.com